Critiquing a Quantitative Study

1919 Words4 Pages

Andrzejowski, J.; Hyle, J.; Eapen, G.; Turnbull, D. (2008), refers to review of literature of previous publications, such as the study by Vanni and colleagues. This study showed an notable effect of prewarming, but was flawed both by inadequate power (10 patients per group) and by having a control group that was significantly hypothermic before anesthetic induction. Two additional studies also showed a smaller decrease in core temperature during surgery after a period of prewarming, but neither study warmed patients intraoperatively A large randomized trial of prewarming, by Melling and colleagues involved more than 400 patients. Their study looked for differences in postoperative complications and showed a significant decrease in postoperative wound infections in patients who were prewarmed either locally or systemically. The authors suggested that prewarming improved peripheral circulation in the preoperative period, thus increasing tissue oxygenation (Andrzejowski, Hyle, Eapen & Turnbull, 2008).

Theoretical of Conceptual Framework

A theoretical framework was not clearly spelled out in this research article; however research on prewarming patients in the surgical setting can be easily based on the Neuman Systems Model. This model focuses on client assessment and response to environmental stressors which is consistent with the practice of prewarming surgical patients. In this model, human beings are described as systems that consciously and unconsciously create their environments both within and around themselves (Avlward, 2010). Prewarming patients is a primary prevention intervention in relation to the Neuman Systems Model. When patients arrive in the preoperative holding area, they usually are not hypothermic. If nurses app...

... middle of paper ...

...A. Davis Company.

British Journal of Anesthesia. (2009, January). Effect of prewarming on patients undergoing general anesthesia. AORN, 89(1), 209-210.

Burns, N., & Grove, S. K. (2009). Strategies for promoting evidence-based nursing practice. In The practice of nursing research (pp. 616-638). St. Louis, Missouri: Saunders.

Cooper, S. (2006, May). The effects of preoperative warming on patients'postoperative temperatures. AORN, 83(5), 1074-1084.

Laureate Education, I. (Producer). (2010). Research analysis [DVD]. In Foundations in nursing practice.

Laureate Education, I. (Producer). (2010). Research design [DVD]. In Foundations in nursing practice.

Reavy, K., & Tavernier, S. (2008, April). Nurses reclaiming ownership to their practice: Implementation of an evidence-based practice model and process. The Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 39(4), 166-172.

Open Document