Comparing and Contrasting the Wars in Chechnya

1882 Words4 Pages

In 1993, Chechnya declared independence from Russia and has since fought for their independence from Russia (Vendina, Belozerov, and Gustafson, “The Wars in Chechnya nd Their Effects on Neighboring Regions,” p. 180). Many critics cite ethnic separatism or economic independence as the reason for the passionate Chechen secessionist movement, but political pressure from radical supporters of Chechen leaders is probably a more accurate explanation. Yeltsin and Putin had different political reasons for their wars in Chechnya, but the Chechen opposition also changed between the two wars, from the Chechen rebel state to individual Chechen warlords and groups. In particular, Russian leaders were enacting a policy of containment in Chechnya, while Chechen leaders shifted from demanding Chechen independence to being instruments of Russian efforts to contain the conflict to Chechnya. The main difference between the two wars was the catalyst for the war, but the underlying reasons for going to war were very similar. President Boris Yeltsin decided to invade Chechnya due to a perceived need to demonstrate that the Russian government was strong and capable of suppressing such an uprising. Yeltsin had a political agenda in which the priority was to institute a federal state where local governments took on a larger role compared to the former soviet state (Hughes, “From Federalisation to Recentralisation,” p. 129). Yeltsin was decentralizing power by granting more legislative powers to the regional governments, but Yeltsin still needed political support from the regional governors in order to pass legislation in the upper house of the Duma (Zhuravskaya, “Federalism in Russia,” p. 61). So Yeltsin started granting selective concessions to carefully... ... middle of paper ... ...r’s position. Ramzan Kadyrov’s strong military presence and the extreme warlords’ disappearance both contribute to less violence in Chechnya, but the conflict instead is expanding to the greater North Caucasus. Russian actors were focused on containing Chechen criminality and instability to Chechnya and Chechen actors shifted from fighting for independence to becoming puppets for the Russian government. However, the different catalysts of the two wars – the first being a response to a declaration of independence and the second being a response to terrorism – are the most significant differences when determining the causality of the wars. Works Cited Treisman, Daniel, "The Return" Vendina, Belozerov, and Gustafson, “The Wars in Chechnya nd Their Effects on Neighboring Regions” Hughes, “From Federalisation to Recentralisation” Zhuravskaya, “Federalism in Russia”

Open Document