The Clinical Effectiveness of Exercise Training for Patients With Chronic Heart Failure Critique

2019 Words5 Pages

Leslie and Buckley (2010) stated that the population they studied was Caucasian males and females between the ages of 47 and 81 years of age. There were twenty two total participants 18 were male and 4 were female. The intervention was identified as

Patients attended outpatient supervised exercise training sessions twice a week for 12 weeks…. Each session began with a 10 to 15 minute warm up period, consisting of free arm and leg movements, stretches and breathing exercises. This was followed by 22 minutes of exercise training, comprising of aerobic and low intensity resistance exercises…. A 10 minute cool down period completed the exercise session, followed by 10 minutes of relaxation (Leslie & Buckley, 2010 p. 135).

In the article The Clinical Effectiveness of Exercise Training for Patients with Chronic Heart Failure, functional capacity, validated measure of quality of life (QOL), New York Heart Association (NYHA) classification, and brain natriuretic peptide (BNP) were the defined outcome measures.

Randomized Controlled Trial

The study by Leslie and Buckley (2010) is not a randomized controlled trial. To have a randomized controlled trial according to Knapp (1998), a trial is carried out with two groups. One of the groups is a treatment group and the other is a control group. In the study Leslie and Buckley (2010) there is one group and they are all given the intervention. This would be more of a correlation study. The writer believes that a correlational study was the correct study to do with the limited amount of research on this topic. There needs to be a starting point for the research to continue. The some data that came out of from this study showed to be significant. The writer believes that the research is worth ...

... middle of paper ...

... thinks that practice should not change. This is because there was no real statistical significance. There was clinical significance that could encourage a small amount of change. This change would be to implement exercise programs for CHF patients to help the functional capacity of their day to day lives. The writer does think that more evidence needs to be shown to implement a practice of exercise with CHF patients, and that would be to show a particular exercise program that would work.

Works Cited

Kanpp, T. R. (1998). Quantitative Nursing Research. United Kingdom: SAGE Publications.

Leslie, R., & Buckley, J. P. (2010, March). The clinical effectiveness of exercise training for

patients with chronic heart failure. British Journal of Cardiac Nursing, 5, 133-139. Retrieved

from http://www.cinahl.com/cgi-bin/refsvc?jid=3462&accno=2010605636

Open Document