Gun control and the Second Amendment
The United States Constitution says that U.S. Citizens have the
right to bear arms. Even though this guarantee was written with no
constraints, there are now laws that limit certain aspects of gun
ownership. The reasons for gun control fall under the flag of public
safety. Though there are many safety reasons why private ownership of
firearms should be banned, these arguments are outweighed not only by the
need for protection, but because the limitation of ownership rights could
become dangerous to personal freedom.
When the U.S. Constitution was written, some delegates thought
Militia was military forces because the Federal Government had its own army
to protect the people. The second amendment was made in response to the
fear of being helpless before a standing professional army. "Aristotle
said that decisions of a leader 'backed by a standing army' would be
different from those made by a leader 'awed by the fear of an armed
people'" (The Commission on the Bicentennial of the United States
Constitution, 28). Elbridge Gerry, a delagate to the Constitutional
convention from Massachusetts, was an activist for the right of the Militia
to bear arms. When asked what use a Militia has, he responded: "What sir,
is the use of a Militia? It is to prevent the establishment of a standing
army, the bane of liberty" (The Commission of the Bicentennial of the
United States Constitution, 26). On December 15, 1791, Virginia ratified
the Bill of Rights, making it, with the second amendment, part of the
constitution (The Commission for the Bicentennial of the United States
Constitution, 5).
The Constitution does not guarantee gun ownership for just any
reason. The second amendment makes it clear that only a well regulated
Militia needs arms. "As recently as 1980 the Supreme Court noted that 'The
second amendment guarantees no right to keep and bear a firearm that does
not have some reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of
a well regulated Militia'"(Isaacson, 163). The meaning of the second
amendment, as interpreted by pro-gun control supporters, was to enable
citizens to protect themselves from and oppressive government, not to allow
anyone the power to shoot another human being.
The main reason for gun control boils down to the want for personal
and public safety. One upsetting fact about guns is they increase the
severity of a crime. "With guns, unlike knives or hands, rage and
recklessness are likely to be translated cleanly and quickly into death"
(Isaacson, 162). Another upsetting fact is that hand guns are people
killers, that is their only use. "With fewer handguns, there are fewer
chances to use them. It is as simple as that" (Isaacson, 162). People
with guns are more likely to take a life that with upclose and personal
weapons like the knife or the fist.
Gun control activists believe that a ban on hand guns would
gradually deplete the number of handguns in circulation. This would slowly
take care of the cheep Saturday Night Specials, which hold no use to police
or sports men, because they only last about 10 years. Little pistols are
not needed by ordinary people and can easily be concealed be street
criminals. "One in every nine Americans has already been threatened or
shot by someone wielding a hand gun"(Isaacson, 162). This statistic shows
the effect of the availability of handguns on America. The handgun is not
needed except when a person wants to hide a weapon. For home defense, the
shotgun is more effective with its wide blasting stopping power, while a
handgun has to be aimed exactly on target.
A big problem with keeping guns in the house is the curiosity and
ignorance of children. Children are more capable of finding guns than they
are given credit for. "Children under the age of 15 suffer approximately
one-third of the deaths caused by guns in the ho me" (Cruit, 18).
Even if a child is well behaved and listens when they are told not to touch
a gun, they may still cecum to peer pressure and let their friends play
with a gun. Not only is a gun dangerous to children, but the ammunition is
as well. A child could be seriously hurt by an exploding bullet which can
be set off by being hit by a rock, a nail, or being thrown into the
fireplace. Children are unpredictable and they do not know the effect of a
gun on themselves or their friends.
Having a gun in the house can also be dangerous because of
temperament, rage, and impulse because murder is usually a crime of passion.
"If you or someone in your family has a hot temper that leads to rather
violent reactions, you should not keep a gun around" (Cruit, 23). Guns are
an easy solution to problems in and enraged person's mind. They are quick
and clean and most of all impersonal. Enraged people are impulsive and
handguns make impulsive actions deadly. "In and all-too-typical case: A
retired railroad worker in San Francisco who bought a gun to protect
against muggers used it in 1982 to kill a neighbor in an argument over a
parking space" (Isaacson, 163).
A gun makes suicide easy and instantaneous. Thousands of people a
year commit suicide because of hopelessness and depression. "Although
there's no way of knowing if all these people would have taken their lives
by other means if a gun had been unavailable, it is reasonable to assume
that some of them would not have done so" (Cruit, 17). According to Julian
S. Hatcher, in Firearms Investigation, Identification, and Evidence, most
people would not actually commit suicide if their were no guns available.
He states "The chance of suicide if no firearm is present is relatively
remote" (Hatcher, 284). Many people who take pills or slit their wrists
think better of it before it is too late and ask for help.
Alcohol and drugs play a big role in the misuse of firearms.
People who have substance abuse problems may play and joke around with a
firearm, creating a hazardous situation. "Fifty-two percent of all
murderers act under the influence of liquor or drugs" (Cruit, 17).
Drinking or doing drugs mix no better with guns than they do with driving
cars. The real danger is that most people with substance problems do not
admit to it and there for do not make a responsible decision with relation
to their problem, when deciding to own a gun or not.
There are other ways to protect yourself that having a gun. Some
of these ways are having fortified outer as well as inner doors, a good
burglar alarm, and a good neighborhood watch organization. Doors need to
be made of strong, solid wood and any windows in them should be out of
reach of the inner locks incase they are broken. "If you have one or more
windows in your door, examine the possibility of breaking one of them from
the outside, reaching in, and unlocking the latch" (Cox, 13). With and
alarm system one can deter a criminal because most will leave at the sound
of an alarm to avoid getting caught. The police can also be alerted with
some systems so a burglar will probably go to another, less troublesome
house. "Now there are all kinds of options available, including automatic
dialing machines to alert a central monitoring station or the police" (Cox,
70). Neighborhood watch is a very effective means of security. In
neighborhood watch people are designated to watch the neighborhood at
different times to make sure its secure. When suspicious things happen,
these people call the police or a civilian base station, "In all
communities, the single most effective aid to deterring crime is the
neighborhood civilian patrol organization" (Mc Gurn, 33). Anti gun
activists believe that it is not necessary to have guns in the hone when
there are various ways to protect yourself without them.
The Constitution says that citizens have the right to bear arms in
the second amendment. Like most of the amendments, the second is written
very broadly so that it can be interpreted in different ways to fit the
changing times. To be able to protect oneself is the most basic right of
individualism and the right to bear arms is a guarantee of individual
freedom. "It protects a basic liberty, one which as a last resort can help
us protect all other rights from those who would oppress us" (Isaacson,
164). One of the main reasons why we have the second amendment is so we
can fight an oppressive government and keep our personal freedoms. "The
right of a citizen to keep and bear arms has justly been considered the
palladium of the liberties of a republic, since it offers a strong moral
check against the usurping and arbitrary powers of rulers" (Isaacson, 165).
Though guns increase the severity of the crimes committed, the
problem is VXK there. One needs to be able to react to an attack with the
same amount of ux: that one is being attacked with. If the person who is
acting violently towards another person has a gun, and the second person
does not, he or she will not be able to defend themselves because a gun is
a long range weapon that cannot be fought against. One can relate this
situation to the differences between the attacking U.S. Military and the
Army of Iraq, who in comparison, were virtually defenseless. A rational
person would want to have their own army as powerful as the opposing one.
Home owned guns are not only dangerous to society, as gun control
activists say, the actually can contribute the safety of the society. In
Hatchers book he tells of a situation in a small South Carolina town. some
outside labor organizers threatened to take over private property. The
next morning a group of local farmers arrived in town with their shotguns.
They were not for either side but private property was sacred to them and
the organizers left hurriedly. "It is remarkable today that those regions
where the family shotgun stands in the corner of the living room or over
the mantel in the style of our ancestors, are almost completely free of
organized crime. Neither tyranny or crime flourishes where citizens both
own and can use weapons" (Hatcher, 332-333).
The problem with the curiosity of children can be easily avoided.
All an adult gun owner needs to do is find a way in which they can hide gun
and stay one step ahead of the child. "You must stay well ahead of your
children. Don't wait until your kids have grown enough to be able to get
to the gun before you move it, you should revise your safety precautions
well in advance of that time. To do otherwise would invite disaster"
(Cruit, 20). Trigger locks and drawer locks with well hidden keys make the
problem of children trivial.
According to gun control activists, there are better ways to
protect oneself from intruders than firearms. If a person really wants to
get into a home a door is not going to stop them. "One basic fact that you
should be aware of, whether you have a gun or not, is that an intruder,
whether a burglar, rapist, drug addict, or psycho, can get into your home
if he wants to badly enough" (Cruit, 15). No matter how strong a door is,
a man with a crowbar can still get in. No matter how much noise a person
makes breaking down a door or setting off an alarm, they will still have
enough time to get to the homeowner before the police get there. Even when
the police are called immediately the y still take time to get there and
sometimes the do not come at all. "Once a criminal is inside your home, he
needs very little time to rape or to kill" (Cruit, 16). If the citizens
are disarmed, what are they to do about a maniac who plans to hurt them and
will not be stopped by a door or and alarm.
The neighborhood watch, though very effective, does not always work.
Most civilians who watch the neighborhoods are asleep when the majority of
crimes happen, in the middle of the night. Looking at a statement made by
McGurn in The Womans Bible for Survival in a Violent Society, "People
become mobilized, they do the job and when the problem subsides, so do
they" (Mc Gurn, 33), it can be seen that after a problem has ended people
stop paying attention. At this time a person could break into a house
unnoticed by neighbors. Now that nobody is watching, the door has been
broken down and a person is inside the house, the homeowner is left to
defend themselves. One big advantage of a gun is that it is a long range
weapon which means long range defence. This means one does not have to get
too close to and assailant when stopping them. "Stay at least eight feet
away, and make sure that no one gets anywhere near him or between the two
of you" (Cruit, 141). With a gun one is safe to sit and wait for the
police, making the criminal stay in one place, without having to touch them
and endanger oneself in the process.
Although guns are very dangerous and are used in all sorts of
criminal activity, they are already out there and the benefits of having
them outweigh the drawbacks. U.S. citizens have the right to bear arms so
that the most basic rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness
can be preserved with force if necessary. Protecting ourselves form others
with deadly force preserves our right to life. Protecting ourselves from
the oppression of a government, with weapons that can threaten it,
preserves our tight to liberty. The preservation of both these rights
contributes directly to the pursuit of happiness because a human being
cannot be happy without life and liberty.Partner sites: Labrador Retriever, Study Spanish in Costa Rica, and Free Essays and Term Papers